The Great 1980s Grease Trap: Why I Miss (and Fear) Long John Silver’s

The Great 1980s Grease Trap: Why I Miss (and Fear) Long John Silver’s

If you grew up in the 1980s, walking into a Long John Silver’s felt like stepping onto a pirate ship docked in the middle of a suburban strip mall. You walked across that wooden, rope lined gangplank to the sound of a clanging ship's bell, ready for a feast that could only be described as glorious, golden-fried perfection.

Back then, my family ate there all the time, and my order never changed. It was always the legendary fish and chicken combo, flanked by a pile of warm hushpuppies. There was something magical about that heavy, crispy batter that coated everything equally, whether it came from the sea or the barnyard. And of course, you couldn't forget the "crunchies", those loose bits of fried batter floating at the bottom of the paper boat that you’d scoop up with a fork after dousing everything in malt vinegar and tartar sauce.

As a kid with an iron stomach, I never thought twice about what was happening behind the counter. Looking back now, I’m half convinced the grease traps at Long John Silver’s in the '80s were seasoned like a cast iron skillet and hardly ever changed. Honestly, that decades old fryer oil was probably the secret ingredient that made the chicken planks and fish fillets taste so unreal.

Fast forward to today, and I haven't stepped foot inside one in over ten years. It’s wild how a place that used to be a staple of my childhood has completely faded from my radar. When I’m driving around trying to figure out what to grab for lunch, Long John Silver’s never even crosses my mind anymore.

It’s not hard to see why its popularity has taken a nosedive over the decades. For one, you practically never see commercials for it anymore, making it easy to forget it still exists while burger and chicken chains dominate the airwaves. More than that, American eating habits have shifted. In a world obsessed with grilled options, air fryers, and calorie counts, a restaurant whose entire menu is unapologetically deep fried in heavy batter feels like a relic from another era. Locations have quietly closed down or merged into awkward co-branded spots with KFC or Taco Bell, leaving the nautical giant as a shadow of its former self.

Still, every once in a while, a wave of nostalgia hits me, and I genuinely miss those golden hushpuppies and crispy chicken planks. I’ve been tempted lately to find one of the remaining outposts and relive my youth.

There’s just one catch: I’m not ten years old anymore. If I’m going to take on a full platter of 1980s-style deep-fried seafood and batter crumbs, I’m going to have to plan ahead. Specifically, I’ll need to put in for a personal day at work the next morning, just to give my adult stomach a fighting chance to recover from all that glorious grease.


Get Blogs Emailed To You


About the Author: Thomas Brogan
Find him on X @brogan78 | on Instagram | on Facebook | or on Youtube