In 1979 Bantam Books officially launched the mass market paperback series under the trademarked name Choose Your Own Adventure until 1998. I was born in 1978, so as a child growing up, I spent an embarrassing amount of my childhood reading books out of order on purpose. That was the whole appeal of Choose Your Own Adventure books. You'd get a few pages in, hit a decision, and then flip to whatever page corresponded to the choice you wanted to make. Turn left or turn right. Open the door or walk away. Trust the stranger or don't. Every choice branched into a completely different story, and if things went badly (and in these books, things went badly constantly), you could just flip back and try again like nothing happened.
Looking back, I think those books quietly taught me more about decision making than almost anything else I read as a kid. Mostly because they were the first place I really understood, on a gut level, that different choices lead to genuinely different outcomes, not just different details.
The Fantasy Wasn't the Adventure, It Was the Redo Button
If I'm honest with myself, the real appeal of those books was never really the pirate ships or haunted houses or space stations. It was the fact that a bad ending wasn't actually the end. You could just go back, make a different choice, and try again with zero consequences carried forward. As a kid, that felt like a superpower. As an adult, I think about that structure constantly, mostly because real life stubbornly refuses to work that way.
What If Life Actually Worked Like That?
I've spent more time than I'd like to admit imagining what it would actually be like if real life had that same branching, flip back and try again structure. Not in a heavy, philosophical way, more like an honest daydream. What if every real decision came with a visible page number for the alternative?
Picture standing at some ordinary crossroads, a job offer, a big move, a conversation you're nervous to have, and being able to see, right there in bold type, "If you take the job, turn to page 118. If you turn it down, turn to page 145." Some part of me thinks that would remove all the anxiety of decision making. Another part of me suspects it would remove something important about actually growing from those decisions in the first place.
The Uncomfortable Lesson Hiding Underneath the Fun
Here's the thing those books never quite told you outright, but that I think I absorbed anyway. Even in a world where you can flip back and retry, the actual decision still had to be made in the first place. You still had to commit to a page number and see where it led. The redo button didn't remove the choice, it just softened the cost of getting it wrong.
Real life doesn't offer that softening. There's no flipping back to page 42 after a decision goes sideways. But I think that's exactly why those books stuck with me so much. They were low stakes practice for a skill that turns out to matter constantly, actually committing to a choice instead of hovering indefinitely, afraid to turn any page at all.
What I'd Actually Want From a Real Life Version
If I could genuinely have one piece of that Choose Your Own Adventure structure in real life, it wouldn't be the ability to undo choices. It would be the visibility. Just being able to see, even roughly, what page 118 versus page 145 actually looked like before committing. Not a guarantee, just a glimpse. Adulthood, as it turns out, is mostly making page 118 or page 145 decisions with absolutely no preview of either page, and then living entirely with whichever one you picked.
I don't actually think I'd want life to work exactly like those books did, growth kind of requires the stakes to be real. But I'm genuinely grateful they gave me a low pressure place to practice the basic, uncomfortable act of choosing a page and turning to it, instead of just sitting frozen at the fork in the road. Turns out that's most of what adult life actually asks of you anyway.
 |
| Find him on X @brogan78 | on Instagram | on Facebook | or on Youtube |